As New York State’s second-largest city, Buffalo is a destination for millions of visitors each year. Situated along the shore of Lake Erie, it’s known for gorgeous architecture, the arts, and a thriving restaurant scene. 

Buffalo is often lumped together with its nearest neighbor, Niagara Falls, which is also a huge destination for visitors. But we know that Buffalo, the home of the Bills and the famous wings, deserves to shine in its own light. 

Places to stay in town range from big chain hotels to boutique hotels. There are, however, a number of affordable accommodation options including an awesome hostel if you know where to look (pssst, it’s here, look right here.).

Check out our favorite Buffalo hostel, and some more cheap and cheerful places to stay.

Quick Answer: Best Hostels in Buffalo

Buffalo to Niagara Falls New York

What to Expect from Hostels in Buffalo 

Let’s be real. There is only one true hostel in Buffalo. But that didn’t stop us from checking out all the different types of places to stay in and around town. 

Typically, hotels in Buffalo are quite pricey – starting around $75 and quickly jumping above $100 bucks a night. Folks looking to keep things on the lower end are better off considering shared accommodation. Prices at a hostel begin as low as $40, while locals typically ask for at least $50 to stay in their guest room. Anything lower than this and you’ll be couch surfing, which is always a possibility, but we’ve left that out of the selections here.

Affordable places to stay are scattered throughout Buffalo. Some are downtown, while others are further out in the suburbs. Considering how you plan to get around town may be a deciding factor as to what neighborhood you want to be in. 

Getting around town is relatively easy! Buffalo’s Metro Public Transportation includes an extensive bus system throughout the area and a rail line in the city center. Totally cost-effective, the rail line’s Free Fare Zone in the core of the city means it’s easy to get to places quickly downtown without having to pay.

The bus costs only $2 a ride, and will take you all the way to Niagara Falls for that price. What a deal! Most hosts know the value of the Metro and can help guests navigate the system. Buffalo International Airport is just on the outskirts of town and a short ride (car or bus) downtown.

Driving around is most convenient but staying downtown will be more difficult with parking. Ride-hailing apps are easy to use in town if you don’t mind it eating into your travel budget. 

In any town, hostels are a great way to travel. The communal spaces promote a friendly vibe and help keep costs low. Although there is only one traditional hostel in Buffalo, there are a number of accommodations that have this same feel and comfort, even though they don’t have the title of “hostel”. Most places offer free Wi-Fi, linens, and a shared kitchen. Make sure to keep an eye out for those who require a minimum night stay because there are more than one.

Remember: an informed traveler is the best kind of traveler. So, let’s get you informed!

Best Hostels in Buffalo

Now that you know what to expect from a hostel and other cost-efficient accommodations in Buffalo in general, let’s break it down place by place. Dive in to see what makes each stand apart from the next!

Things DO go missing sometimes…

lock iconPsst! Heading to a hostel? Don’t forget to pack a padlock! It’s well worth having one so you can secure your locker and protect your stuff!

Best Overall Hostel in Buffalo – Buffalo Niagara Hostel

Buffalo Niagara Hostel
  • $
  • Located in the Theatre District/Downtown 
  • Private & (Single or Mixed Gender) Dorm Rooms
  • Bike Loan

Hands-down Buffalo Niagara Hostel is the best hostel in Buffalo.

Okay, okay, yes – Buffalo Niagara Hostel is the only traditional hostel in town, but that’s NOT the reason we named it our best overall hostel. The truth is that it’s a stellar place with great amenities, a chill vibe, and really affordable rates.  

The location can’t be beaten. Perfectly placed downtown, there’s no reason to have a car if you don’t want to. Situated in the heart of the theatre district, there are tons of things to do within walking distance. If you’re a bit tired and don’t want to walk, no worries – Buffalo Niagara Hostel is steps from the Metro Rail line. Better yet, it’s within the “Free Fare Zone”, so you’ll be saving your money while you zip around downtown.

Wanna go a bit farther? Not a problem. The Metro bus will take you just about anywhere, even up to Niagara Falls for only $2 a ride. You can’t complain about that. If you’re up for another way to see the city, the hostel lends bikes to pedal around.

No matter how you get around town, the local staff at Buffalo Niagara has all the ins on where to go and what to see. 

Why you’ll love this hostel:

  • Book Exchange 
  • Free Store
  • Ping Pong

Buffalo Niagara Hostel is a traditional hostel that gets it right. The vibe is all about the friendly backpacker on a journey to discover Buffalo.

It’s designed to give budget-conscious travelers a sweet place to stay. Bunking is where it’s at. Single and mixed-gender dorms let guests choose the right one for themselves. Private rooms are available for small groups, too. This way you and a friend or two can bunk up in your own space – that’s not too shabby. 

Communal spaces are the real reason to choose a hostel, and Buffalo Niagara does not disappoint. Meet other travelers in the lounge, the movie room, or playing ping pong. The full kitchen is spacious and stocked with the basics. There’s even coffee so you can enjoy a cup of joe before heading out to explore the city. 

Other Budget Accommodations in Buffalo

Moreland Guest House

Buffalo Moreland Guest House
  • Located in Iron Island neighborhood 
  • Private Rooms with Shared Bathroom
  • Shared Kitchen

Moreland Guest House is a bit off the beaten path, but it’s definitely worth a look. You’re not going to find it listed on the large booking sites – but insiders know about this gem and the value it can bring to any budget-conscious trip to Buffalo. 

Previously a nun’s convent, Moreland still has that simple, grounded feel. The guest house offers a modest stay in Buffalo with the best rate in town. It’s easy to make yourself at home in the private rooms that have a desk, closet, tv, and free Wi-Fi. Use of the common spaces like the shared kitchen and bathrooms help keep costs down, while the dining and billiards rooms are sweet perks. 

Located in the residential neighborhood of Iron Island, it’s a bit further from the center of the action than other places to stay in Buffalo. But then again, no other places are quite like Moreland. Parking is not an issue if you have your own ride and it’s close to two major bus lines if you’re looking for public transport. 

Moreland is a simple, straightforward place to stay in Buffalo. It’s a good idea to check it out to see if it fits what you’re looking for – the price point definitely is. 

The Inn on Tennyson

The Inn on Tennyson hosted by Carol Buffalo
  • $$
  • Private Room 
  • Yard
  • Pets Welcome

The Inn on Tennyson is a lovely place to stay for any reason that brings you to Buffalo or Niagara. This dog-friendly home is a lovely place with everything visitors are looking for in a great stay. The cozy private room is perfect after a day of exploring the area. While the shared spaces like the kitchen, bathroom, and yard are perks that help keep costs down but make it feel like you’re staying with a friend.   

Like any responsible pet owner, just let the host know ahead of time that your pooch is coming with you. With that and a small pet fee, you’re all set. Shelby is the dog of the house. She’s super friendly, so if you’re traveling with your own pooch or not, she’ll still be super happy to greet you. 

Located in North Buffalo, it’s a great home base to explore the Buffalo-Niagara area. Just north of Delaware Park, it’s an easy drive just about anywhere in town. Street parking in the area isn’t an issue, so not to worry if you have your own car. If you’re taking public transportation, the bus stops on the corner – super convenient.

The neighborhood itself has lots of restaurants, bars, and shops nearby. The host is a Buffalo local so you can’t go wrong with asking for some tips on where to go in town.

Is This the Best Travel Backpack EVER???
nomatic backpack black

We’ve tested countless packs over the years, and now we’ve found our absolute favourite: the nomad-approved Nomatic Backpack.

Want more deetz on why we love it so damn much? Then read our comprehensive review for the inside scoop!

Learn More Now!

Buffalo Airport Hotel

Buffalo Airport Hotel
  • $$ 
  • Near Airport
  • Gym
  • Onsite Bar & Grill

Yes, this is a hotel, but we had to include it on our list for a variety of reasons.

First, its rates are good. Especially if booked in advance, the rates rival many of the cost-effective room shares. Second, it’s right next to the airport and offers shuttle service to the airport and back, so there’s some saved cash in your pocket. Being near the airport doesn’t mean you’re far away from the action – it’s only a 15min drive to downtown Buffalo and 30 mins up to Niagara Falls. If you don’t have your own ride, consider a ride-hailing app or the Metro bus system to get you into town. Since it’s near the airport, a major bus line is nearby. 

The other reality is that staying at a hotel comes with some perks. Enjoy complimentary coffee in your own room before heading out for the day to explore the Buffalo area. Get a workout in at the gym, or enjoy a drink and bite to eat at the Sports 365 Bar & Grill right at the hotel.

The other major feature is that private rooms come with more space than a room share, a TV, and your very own bathroom. Let’s say that again: your very own bathroom. Point made.

Boho Bungalow with Fireplace

Boho Bungalow with Fireplace Hosted by Jackie Buffalo
  • $$ 
  • Located in Orchard Park, NY
  • Private Room with Shared Bathroom
  • Fireplace

Imagine returning from a day exploring Buffalo and settling down in front of a fireplace in your very own private room. Does it get any better than that? Not so much. Don’t worry if you’re coming to visit western New York during the dead of winter, the electric fireplace will keep you toasty.

The shared facilities make this space a great place to stay. The shared living room and patios are great places to relax, while the bathroom and kitchen are convenient ways to keep costs down. 

The home is ideally located in Orchard Park, NY which is just south of Buffalo. Public transportation may be a bit of a hassle during a stay here, but ride-hailing apps can do the trick. Street parking is not an issue in this residential neighborhood which makes it easy to zip around the Buffalo area. 

At Boho Bungalow, the host goes above and beyond for guests, offering add-ons that can’t be found elsewhere. For a small fee, you can bring your dog, rent a kayak or bike, get a ride to/from the airport or even enjoy a breakfast basket. It’s like they’ve thought of everything, and wants you to have a great time. 

Buffalo Hostels FAQ

Travel Safety Tips for Buffalo

And don’t forget Travel Insurance! We’ve put together a roundup of Travel Insurance for backpackers – check it out here, or if you’re low on time, get a quote from World Nomads, our favorite travel insurance provider.

world nomads insurance banner

Final Thoughts 

No matter what time of year you come to Buffalo, there are quality places to stay that will be easy on your wallet.

Buffalo Niagara Hostel is the place that balances affordable rates with a fun-loving, traveler’s vibe. Although the other places on our list don’t have the “hostel” title, they are definitely in tune with the needs of the traveler on a budget, so rest assured you’ll find the place for your next trip to the area.


Find out how YOU can support the site.

We work hard to put out the best backpacker resources on the web for free! It’s all about helping out our tribe of awesome backpacker readers (that’s you!). Please visit the link to find out how you can help keep the site going 🙂

For the sake of transparency, some of the links in our content are affiliate links. This means that if you book your accommodation, buy a piece of gear, or sort your insurance through our link, we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only link to stuff that members of the Broke Backpacker team has actually used and never endorse products or services that are not up to scratch. Thanks for your support!