Where to Stay in Fort Myers (COOLEST Areas!)

FIRST TIME IN FORT MYERS

FIRST TIME IN FORT MYERS

Fort Myers Beach

Fort Myers is famous for its beaches. They have everything you could want from a beach, from warm sunny waters to lots of opportunities for outdoor activities. And the Fort Myers Beach is one of the best of the bunch.

CHECK TOP HOTEL CHECK TOP AIRBNB

ON A BUDGET

ON A BUDGET

Downtown

The Downtown area is the best neighborhood to stay in Fort Myers if you don’t want to spend all your time at the beach. It’s located along the Caloosahatchee river, which is why it’s full of historical and ecological attractions.

CHECK TOP AIRBNB CHECK TOP HOTEL

FOR FAMILIES

FOR FAMILIES

Isla de Sanibel

If you like the beach but would prefer to be away from the noise and busyness of the main areas, then this island is for you.

CHECK TOP AIRBNB CHECK TOP HOTEL

Fort Myers is a relatively small city, but that doesn’t mean that it’s all the same. In fact, there are a range of cool neighborhoods to choose from when you decide to travel there.

Just be aware that the public transport isn’t the best, so you should stay within walking distance of the attractions you most want to see or hire a car.

If you want to enjoy the sun, sand, and surf, then Fort Myers Beach is hands down the best neighborhood in Fort Myers to stay in. It’s close to other beaches as well to Captiva and Sanibel islands and is surrounded by shops, restaurants, and accommodation options.

The second area to consider is Fort Myer’s Downtown. This is one of Fort Myer’s best neighborhoods for clubbing and restaurants, and it also has some amazing shopping options as well. It’s also a great choice when you’re deciding where to stay in Fort Myers on a budget.

Just off the coast of the city, there are some great places to stay in Sanibel Island. It offers the best of all worlds: great beaches, restaurants, shopping, and amazing natural areas where you can enjoy some peace and quiet.

You might need a little help to find the coolest places to stay in Fort Myers. So, while you’re booking your trip, make sure you check the following areas.

1. Fort Myers Beach – Where to Stay in Fort Myers First Time

Fort Myers is famous for its beaches. They have everything you could want from a beach, from warm sunny waters to lots of opportunities for outdoor activities. And the Fort Myers Beach is one of the best of the bunch.

It’s located on a 7-mile-long barrier island just off the mainland. And the beach is wide, nicely sloping, and has sugary sand that feels great underfoot.

If you’re trying to decide where to stay in Fort Myers for one night, then this is the best choice. But it’s also a good area to stay in if you’re visiting for longer.

There is seemingly no end to the outdoor activities you can enjoy in this part of the city. And there are also lots of Fort Myers accommodation options available close by no matter what much money you’re looking to spend.

The Broke Backpacker is supported by you. Clicking through our links may earn us a small affiliate commission, and that's what allows us to keep producing free content 🙂 Learn more.

Top Things to Do in Fort Myers Beach

1. Go swimming of course!
2. Try some outdoor activities like fishing or watersports.
3. Head out and spend some money in the local shops.
4. Just relax on the beach or by the pool with a drink in hand.
5. Head to the Downtown area to experience Fort Myer’s history.
6. Visit the archaeological site at Mound House.
7. Head up to Bowditch Point Park for hiking and amazing views.

Best Hotel in Fort Myers Beach: Best Western Plus Beach Resort

This hotel in Fort Myers offers convenient access to the beach as well as comfortable surroundings. It has its own private beach and outdoor pool, a playground for the kids, a golf course and air-conditioned rooms with all the usual amenities.

It’s also close to prime fishing and watersports areas.

Best Airbnb in Fort Myers Beach: Scenic Retreat with Private Balcony

Hence the name, this apartment is cushty little spot for couples or digital nomads. Less than a mile from Times Square, the beach centre and the remains of the pier, you really couldn’t be in a better location. You’ve got a large double bed, a living area and a fully equipped kitchen, so there’s no doubt you’ll feel right at home. The beach is less than a five-minute walk, and if you’re lucky, you might even spot a dolphin or a Manta ray.

Best Luxury Hotel in Fort Myers Beach: Margaritaville Beach Resort

Whether you’re trying to decide where to stay in Fort Myers for families or on your own, this luxury hotel is a great choice. It offers everything you could want for a relaxed, lavish stay.

There’s a grand outdoor pool, a gym and a bar for your ‘fuck it I’m on holiday’ cocktail at 11 am. And the rooms are elegant, fully equipped, and come in a range of sizes. Plus, you’re on the beachfront, so you don’t have to go far to feel the sand between your toes.

2. Downtown – Where to Stay in St. Fort Myers on a Budget

The Downtown area is the best neighborhood to stay in Fort Myers if you don’t want to spend all your time at the beach. It’s located along the Caloosahatchee River, which is why it’s full of historical and ecological attractions.

Unfortunately, the Downtown area is a fair distance from the beach, so you will probably need to have to a car if you want to make frequent trips to the ocean.

The clubs, bars and restaurants are awesome in this part of the city, which makes it a great choice when you’re deciding where to stay in Fort Myers for nightlife. And you mustn’t forget about the shopping either, because the city is full of outdoor shopping centers and vintage stores that will keep you busy for days.

Top Things to Do in Downtown

1. Head out to experience the best nightlife in the city.
2. Spend a day on the beach, working on your tan and trying watersports.
3. Go shopping and check out the vintage stores and outdoor shopping centers.
4. Take a tour through the Edison and Ford Winter Estate.
5. Check out the Burroughs Home and Gardens.
6. Experience the local art scene, starting at the Sidney and Berne Davis Art Center.
7. Take a boat trip up the Caloosahatchee River.
8. Learn to sail at the Edison Sailing Center.
9. Take a walk through the River District, the coolest area in Fort Myers and experience amazing food and a perfect mix of the present and the past.

Best Airbnb in Downtown: Studio Orlando in Fort Myers

If you want to be in the Downtown area, this apartment is a great choice. Not only is it in the best area in Fort Myers to stay in for each access to all the city shops and restaurants, it’s also close to the Historic District.

The studio apartment is stylish, has a view of the gardens, and offers a fully equipped kitchen and bathroom that you can use.

Best Luxury Hotel in Downtown: Luminary Hotel & Co

If you’re searching for a swanky hotel with some mean views, then Luminary Hotel & Co is perfect for you, my friend. The location is an ideal base for exploring, provided you want to leave your extremely comfy bed and lavish room. After a sublime night’s sleep, wonder on down to the breakfast area where you can feast on a variety of options and fuel up for a day of adventure or slothing around, going full do not disturb mode (no judgement here).

Best Hotel in Downtown: Hampton Inn

Clean, modern, affordable. If that sounds like a bit of you, then the Hampton Inn is a solid choice. Enjoy a handsome room with a snug bed that will make fighting the urge to hit the snooze button near impossible. Once you roll, spring or slide out of bed, you can head down for a delectable banquet of dishes at the buffet breakfast before a day of adventures. There is a fitness room, an all-year-round pool and a lounge area if you fancy opening your laptop and pretending to look busy. Overall, a tidy option in a handy location that isn’t going to drain the bank.

3. Isla de Sanibel – Best Neighborhood in Fort Myers for Families

If you like the beach but would prefer to be away from the noise and busyness of the main areas, then this island is for you. It’s one of the best places to stay in Fort Myers for all types of travelers, from honeymooners to families, as it offers a great mix of attractions and activities.

And it’s just off the coast of the city, so you can easily head in there to explore whenever you choose.

Sanibel Island offers everything. It has museums, theaters, awesome bars and clubs as well as live music venues. But most of the island has been left to nature, which means you can enjoy lots of outdoor activities as well.

The fishing, hiking, and bird watching are absolutely first-rate on Sanibel. And as for the food? Well, as long as you choose the fresh seafood, you definitely won’t be disappointed.

Top Things to Do in Isla de Sanibel

1. Try as many of the local restaurants as you can and eat seafood!
2. Head out for a day of culture and explore the local art galleries.
3. Spend your days on the beach relaxing or trying watersports.
4. Head out with friends to the local bars or check out the live music scene.
5. Learn more about the local region at the Sanibel Historical Museum and Village or the Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum.
6. Head out for a night of culture at the BIG ARTS Strauss Theater and see a play, musical, or comedy.
7. This is the best area in Fort Myers to stay in for luxury accommodation options, so make sure you indulge yourself a little!

Best Airbnb in Isla de Sanibel: Sanibel beachfront Condo

When properties have beachfront in the title, I’m always a little suspicious, you arrive and realise the beach is actually two taxis and a 10-minute hike away. However Sanibel beachfront Condo, you will literally have the golden sand as your backyard. Inside, you’ll feel right at home, with a snug living area and two inviting bedrooms ideal for an uninterrupted night’s sleep. After you’ve arisen, chef up some delicious eggs on toast and espresso in your fully equipped kitchen and tuck in on your scenic balcony. If you’re looking for a beachy escape, look no further.

Best Hotel in Isla de Sanibel: Island Inn

A shell collector and beach lover’s paradise. Backed onto the white side and glistening waters, the Island Inn is what dreams are made of. Enjoy a cosy living space with a fully equipped kitchen and cushty bedroom. If you’re travelling as a couple looking for a romantic getaway or in need of some rest and recovery, this is the perfect place for you.

Best Luxury Hotel in Isla de Sanibel: Sanibel Inn

Whether you’re looking for a quiet and peaceful weekend away or a family holiday in the sun the Sanibel Inn is a solid choice. You’re located in the perfect spot, a short stroll from restaurants, shops and cafes if you want to explore the island. Plus, you won’t be short of ways to spend your days, relaxing by the pool, taking a kayak or bikes for a spin or just reading a book with a ‘it’s 5 o’clock somewhere’ cocktail in hand. The rooms are a snug sanctuary with inviting beds, dreamy balconies and a fully equipped kitchen if you want to show off your pot noodle making skills. Overall, for the price, location and lavish touches, the Sanibel Inn is tough to beat.

Here’s what people usually ask us about the areas of Fort Myers and where to stay.

ALWAYS sort out your backpacker insurance before your trip. There’s plenty to choose from in that department, but a good place to start is Safety Wing.

They offer month-to-month payments, no lock-in contracts, and require absolutely no itineraries: that’s the exact kind of insurance long-term travellers and digital nomads need.

SafetyWing is cheap, easy, and admin-free: just sign up lickety-split so you can get back to it!

Click the button below to learn more about SafetyWing’s setup or read our insider review for the full tasty scoop.

Whether you’re trying to decide where to stay in Fort Myers for nightlife or for a quieter, more relaxed stay, you need to choose the right neighborhood. And with our Fort Myers neighborhood guide, that will be much simpler to do.

Then you can get on with just enjoying your time in the sun and the sand! And don’t forget to do some shopping while you’re there too.