Indianapolis, or ‘Indy’ to its friends, is the state capital and most populous city in the state of Indiana. Not to mention one that it’s of the coolest cities in the Midwest!

But deciding where to stay in this colossal city can be a challenge. That’s why our expert travel writers have put this guide together, to help you find the right neighborhood and the right hotel for you.

Whatever your interests, you will find plenty of entertainment, attractions and places to unwind in Indianapolis. Simply follow our guide to find the best neighborhood to stay in Indianapolis to suit your vacation style and your budget!

Let’s get started with the best areas to stay in Indianapolis.

Where to Stay in Indianapolis

Looking for a specific place to stay? These are the best places to stay in Indianapolis.

Best Airbnb in Indianapolis – Modern, Mid Century Vibes – 1br with city views!

This sleek apartment in the coveted south Mile Square neighborhood comes with some extremely boutique decor. It has an inviting private balcony with awesome views overlooking the skyline and the canal.

There’s a state of the art gym and even a rooftop infinity pool! The whole space is for rent.

Best Affordable Hotel in Indianapolis Holiday Inn Indianapolis Downtown

This simple, comfortable 3-star hotel has 130 rooms and has been recently refurbished. The front desk operates around the clock and the location is perfectly poised to explore Downtown Indianapolis.

An indoor pool and gym are on-site for guests to enjoy. The rates are very budget-friendly, standards are high.

Best Mid-Range Hotel in Indianapolis – The Westin Indianapolis

The Westin is a convenient 5-minute walk from the major tourist attractions of Mile Square. The accommodation is of a 4-star standard, yet prices are not too steep for such a central hotel.

Guests can enjoy using the hotel’s indoor pool and fitness centre. There are rooms suitable for families.

Indianapolis Neighborhood Guide

FIRST TIME IN INDIANAPOLIS
indianapolis - mile square
FIRST TIME IN INDIANAPOLIS

Mile Square

Historic Mile Square is Indianapolis’s small, compact Downtown area. It earned its nickname for the original square mile that formed the foundations of the city. Since 1820, the city has expanded but Mile Square remains the bustling centre.

ON A BUDGET
wikicommons - indianapolis - lockerbie square
ON A BUDGET

Lockerbie Square

To the east of Mile Square sits the lively quarters of Lockerbie Square, which is, in fact, the oldest surviving neighborhood in Indianapolis! Cobblestone streets and grand 19th century residences shape the elegant look of this picturesque district.

NIGHTLIFE
wikicommons - indianapolis - fletcher place
NIGHTLIFE

Fletcher Place

Fletcher Place is a hip little ‘hood to the south-east of Mile Square. It is another district noted for its historical architecture, comprising Gothic Revival and Italianate styles so it is well worth an amble.

COOLEST PLACE TO STAY
wikicommons - indianapolis - fountain square
COOLEST PLACE TO STAY

Fountain Square

Fountain Square is a quirky neighborhood found a mile and a half to the south east of Mile Square. The neighborhood is infinitely cool, with galleries, laid-back eateries and cafes and offbeat nightlife.

FOR FAMILIES
shutterstock - indianapolis - broad ripple
FOR FAMILIES

Broad Ripple

Broad Ripple is a serene settlement 8.5 miles north of Mile Square. It offers a rural setting for your vacation surrounded by lush greenery and the gushing White River.

The city of Indianapolis is divided into a whopping 99 community areas in total! These are further broken down into smaller neighborhoods.

On the whole, these regions are extremely walkable – which is part of the city’s appeal. Indianapolis boasts six unique Cultural Districts, four of which can be found within Downtown Indianapolis.

These are all distinguished by their own individual characteristics.

To the west of the city, the White River runs its course from north to south. A series of canals spurt from this, providing ample walking and cycling opportunities along the waterways.

The city is home to two major sports clubs – the Indiana Pacers (NBA) and the Indianapolis Colts (NFL). There is also the University of Indianapolis along with a number of other educational institutions.

The Downtown district of Indianapolis is known as Mile Square. Here is where you’ll find the top landmarks, stellar eateries and also some lively nightlife options.

If you’re looking for where to stay in Indianapolis for one night, book your stay in Mile Square.

Lockerbie Square is where you can get your claws on some cheaper accommodation and still find some cool ways to spend your time.

Fletcher Place is the best area in Indianapolis to stay in for nightlife. However, if you’re looking for nightclubs you will find plenty of options in the south end of Mile Square, too!

Fountain Square is the trendiest neighborhood. Stay here if you want to hang with locals and soak up some pure Indy culture. Broad Ripple, a suburb north of Mile Square, has similar laid-back vibes to Fountain Square.

There’s lots of greenery and outdoorsy things to do so the ‘village’ is where to stay in Indianapolis with kids.

Is This the Best Travel Backpack EVER???
nomatic backpack black

We’ve tested countless packs over the years, and now we’ve found our absolute favourite: the nomad-approved Nomatic Backpack.

Want more deetz on why we love it so damn much? Then read our comprehensive review for the inside scoop!

Learn More Now!

5 Best Neighborhoods to Stay in Indianapolis

Let’s take a look at the 5 best neighborhoods to stay in Indianapolis. They’re each a little different, depending on the type of experience you’re after.

#1 Mile Square – Where to Stay in Indianapolis First Time

Historic Mile Square is Indianapolis’s small, compact Downtown area. It earned its nickname for the original square mile that formed the foundations of the city. Since 1820, the city has expanded but Mile Square remains the bustling centre.

Mile Square is where you’ll find most of the key attractions and notable buildings, making it a great place to stay in Indianapolis for your first time. The neighborhood is pretty walkable too, bonus!

indianapolis - mile square

You’ll find plenty of places to eat and unwind with a drink in the evening. To get to other neighborhoods within Indianapolis, you can use the city’s excellent public bus system.

Things to See and Do in Mile Square:

– Take a tour of the Indiana State House, home to the state government

– Delve into the culture and art of the American West at the Eiteljorg Museum

– Visit the epicenter of Mile Square by paying your respects at the iconic Soldiers and Sailors War Monument within Monument Circle

– Take a walk along Canal Walk

– Catch a basketball game at the Bankers Life Fieldhouse, home turf of the NBA league Indiana Pacers

– Soak up speakeasy vibes at the 1933 cocktail lounge

– Browse world-class sculpture at Gallery Forty-Two

– Check out a free performance or art exhibition at the Artsgarden

– Visit the Indiana World War Memorial which commemorates the soldiers who fell in WWI and also features a war museum

– Enjoy hearty all-American fare at the Rock Bottom Restaurant and Brewery

– Beat the drums at the highly interactive percussion museum, the Rhythm! Discovery Centre

Best Airbnb in Mile Square Unbeatable Location! 2br apt in heart of the city

The location doesn’t get much better than this! The apartment can fit 6 people across two bedrooms and the additional use of the sofa bed and air mattress.

You can check-in easily using the front desk and book with assurance of a ‘superhost’ rated host. Ideal for central sightseeing.

Best Affordable Hotel in Mile Square Sheraton Indianapolis City Centre Hotel

Right in the very core of the city, you won’t need to walk far to find places to eat and things to do! This hotel comes with an outdoor pool, a Jacuzzi and a rooftop terrace – all for a very respectable rate.

Rooms are equipped with hot drink making facilities.

Best Hotel in Mile Square Embassy Suites Indianapolis

This star hotel provides a spa, wellness centre, sauna and an indoor pool. All rooms and suites are impeccable and there is an on-site bar and restaurant if you don’t fancy eating out.

The hotel offers an express check-in and check-out feature, a car rental service and a tour desk.

#2 Lockerbie Square – Where to Stay in Indianapolis on a Budget

To the east of Mile Square sits the lively quarters of Lockerbie Square, which is, in fact, the oldest surviving neighborhood in Indianapolis!

Cobblestone streets and grand 19th-century residences shape the elegant look of this picturesque district. The architecture is an alluring mix of Italianate, Federal and Queen Anne builds – taking a saunter around these parts takes you back to Indianapolis’s historic past!

wikicommons - indianapolis - lockerbie square
source: Vintagejhan (Wikicommons)

Massachusetts Avenue injects modern-day energy into the district and is a great place to take yourself on a self-guided foodie tour – you will find some of the best restaurants, cafes and bars along the strip.

Lockerbie Square is well-connected to the rest of the city center, but is also where you can find some budget accommodation options.

Things to See and Do in Lockerbie Square:

– Drink German beer and eat Bavarian specialities at The Rathskellar

– Visit the residence of James Whitcom Riley, a distinguished poet and writer who was known as the ‘Hoosier Poet’ and also the ‘Children’s Poet’

– Get lost among the pretty streets and historic buildings

– Buy quirky, locally sourced merchandise at Silver in the City

– Sip wine at the Easley Winery. Check out their wine tasting deals and happy hour prices to keep the price low! Or, have a locally crafted brew at the Lockerbie Pub!

– Go restaurant hopping on Massachusetts Avenue; cool down with something sweet at Sub Zero Nitrogen Ice Cream!

– Admire the beautifully Gothic, German-style St Mary’s Catholic Church

– Find out what’s on at the Old National Centre, a hub for live music and touring theatrical shows

Best Airbnb in Lockerbie Square Upscale 1br apt in hip and trendy Mass Ave area

This one bed, one bathroom apartment can fit four guests by making use of the sofa bed and air mattress provided. Guests have the entire apartment to themselves. Although it’s considered a budget accommodation, it’s one of the overall best Airbnbs in Indianapolis.

A spacious, fully equipped kitchen means guests can prepare meals. The location is awesome – you can walk to all the local attractions!

Best Affordable Hotel in Lockerbie Square – The Harney House Inn

This small, cozy inn boasts three bedrooms decorated in a quaint, very welcoming style. The accommodation has a shared area which includes a piano which guests are welcome to use.

The property provides a nourishing breakfast to start your day and complimentary Wi-Fi comes as part of the package.

Best Hotel in Lockerbie Square – Nestle Inn

This small inn has five bedrooms available, each furnished with antique pieces and with immaculate private bathrooms attached. Guests may unwind with a book from the on-site library or make use of the Jacuzzi.

There is a tour desk and concierge available. The rate includes breakfast and Wi-Fi is complimentary.

#3 Fletcher Place – Best Area to Stay in Indianapolis for Nightlife

Fletcher Place is a hip little ‘hood to the south-east of Mile Square. It is another district noted for its historical architecture, comprising Gothic Revival and Italianate styles so it is well worth an amble.

wikicommons - indianapolis - fletcher place
source: Nyttend (Wikicommons)

If you’re looking for the best area to stay in Indianapolis for nightlife, Fletcher Place is for you! The neighborhood has an innovative dining scene, which glides seamlessly into some of the best pubs and bars in town where you can enjoy a laid-back night on the town.

Things to See and Do in Fletcher Place:

– Relax in the green Edna Balz Lacy Park which is popular with families and local dog walkers!

– Choose between a no-frills cup of drip or an artisan coffee at Calvin Fletcher’s Coffee Co.

– Pick up fresh bread and pastries at the neighborhood’s favourite bakery, Amelia’s

– Sit in the eclectic viewpoint at Idle Park where you can watch the split of the interstate highways. If you don’t fancy the alternative to trainspotting, stargaze at night instead

– Hang out at the crowdfunded bar Tappers where you can play arcade games and chug a craft beer

– Visit the 1205 Distillery – a small batch distillery and cocktail lounge which offer a unique drinking experience

– Give your lungs a karaoke work-out at Dugout Bar which is open late Thurs – Sat

– Hop aboard the Pickled Peddlar where you can drink beer and pedal the streets on the electric assisted bike

– Eat contemporary, street food inspired Asian cuisine at Rook – their steamed buns are out of this world!

Best Airbnb in Fletcher Place – Fletcher BnB great walkability safe stylish

This one-bedroom apartment comes with some unique interior touches including a fireplace and elegant columns. In addition to the memory foam mattress and comfy sofa bed, there’s even a hammock to kick back in after a day pursuing the nearby sites.

Netflix and a daily continental breakfast is included!

Best Affordable Hotel in Fletcher Place – Oakwood at The Waverley

These furnished holiday apartments are furnished with all the amenities you will need during your stay. They have kitchen facilities, a lounge area with television and cable, Wi-Fi and private bathrooms.

The complex has a shared outdoor swimming pool so you can take a refreshing dip during the summer months.

Best Hotel in Fletcher Place – The Alexander: A Dolce Hotel

The rooms at this 4-star hotel are designed with an artistic flair, featuring chic decor and funky wall art. Choose between an en suite bedroom or book a unit which comes with its own kitchen, if you wish to prepare your own meals.

Valet parking is available, Wi-Fi is complimentary.

#4 Fountain Square – Coolest Place to Stay in Indianapolis

Fountain Square is a quirky neighborhood found a mile and a half to the south east of Mile Square. The neighborhood is infinitely cool, with galleries, laid-back eateries and cafes and offbeat nightlife.

It’s easily one of the best neighborhoods to stay in Indianapolis!

wikicommons - indianapolis - fountain square
source: Nyttend (Wikicommons)

A wander around the streets will expose you to some vibrant street art, the sounds of street musicians and the aromas of freshly brewed coffee.

You’ll find that most of the activity in Fountain Square is concentrated within the two parallel streets of Virginia Avenue and Shelby Street.

Things to See and Do in Fountain Square:

– Ogle the kitchy antiques and funky memorabilia at the Museum of Psychphonics

– Tumble down the rabbit hole at the White Rabbit Cabaret club with a comedy or burlesque show
– Strike some pins at the Action Duckpin Bowl, a vintage bowling alley from the 1930’s

– Try swing dancing with Naptown Stomp at the Fountain Square Theatre

– Wander the streets to check out the eye-catching street art

– Shop for vinyls, books and vintage clothing at the boutiques on Virginia Avenue and Shelby Street

– Sample local artisan meads and honey wines at the New Day Meadery

– Mingle with the kitties at the Nine Lives Cat Cafe

– Choose between an array of Mexican eateries – La Margarita, El Arado Grill and Revolucion

– Spruce up your lounge new decor from the FLUX warehouse

– Sip a cocktail with a view at the Rooftop Garden Cocktail Club

– Drink wines from around the world at the casual Wine Market

Best Airbnb in Fountain Square – Comfy & Modern Guest Suite Next to Downtown Indy

Guests can have the privilege of having this sparkling clean, contemporary self-contained unit in the heart of the CUltural District all to themselves. Your ‘superhost’ is in the house next door and will stock the fridge with snacks pre-arrival.

Wi-Fi is fast and the area is safe and well-connected.

Best Affordable Hotel in Fountain Square – Sunrise on Shelby Street

This detached, whole home is available for rent in the gorgeous Fountain Square neighborhood. Complimentary Wi-Fi and free parking are available at the guests’ convenience. The house is decorated with love and care, and is suitable for a family stay.

The area is quiet and convenient for accessing local attractions.

Best Hotel in Fountain Square – Retro 1br in Fountain Square

This compact, tastefully designed apartment is beautifully prepared for guests with homely furnishings, a fully equipped kitchen and a spacious bathroom. Strong Wi-Fi is provided for free.

Its location on the cusp of Fountain Square and Fletcher Street means you can reap the best of both of these fabulous districts.

#5 Broad Ripple – Best Neighborhood in Indianapolis for Families

Broad Ripple is a serene settlement 8.5 miles north of Mile Square. It offers a rural setting for your vacation surrounded by lush greenery and the gushing White River.

Both the Red Line and Route 18 connect Broad Ripple to Downtown Indianapolis, so you can still easily access the attractions of the city center.

shutterstock - indianapolis - broad ripple
source: Saeng M (Shutterstock)

The neighborhood is laid-back with a bohemian vibe. It’s known for its global dining scene, hip brewpubs and artisan coffee shops. It’s popular with local families and has plenty of appeal for children.

Those looking for where to stay in Indianapolis with kids – look no further than Broad Ripple!

Things to See and Do in Broad Ripple:

– Catch a gig at famed music venue The Vogue

– Take a picnic to Broad Ripple Park – pack your swimming costume and you can jump in the park’s swimming pool!

– Tuck into healthy food at Public Greens which dishes up vegan delights and chicken plates

– Cruise along the White River on a stunning paddle wheel boat – usually 4 hours

– Eat ice cream and fairtrade coffee at the former train depot, BRICS

– Browse the Indianapolis Arts Centre. This riverside gallery has exhibits, expansive outdoor grounds and even offers a range of classes

– Hike or bike the Monon Rail Trail which runs through Broad Ripple. The total length is 26 miles – decide how far you want to go!

– Spend a day exploring the monuments, sculptures and hilly trails of the nearby Holiday Park

– Gorge on croissants and cakes at Rene’s Bakery

Best Hostel in Broad Ripple – The Indy Hostel

Indianapolis’s one and only hostel is located close to Broad Ripple. Solo travelers can book a dorm bed whilst families can enjoy the three-bed private room. With comfortable, shared living quarters you’ll feel right at home in this quiet hostel.

They even host live music events and run yoga classes.

Best Airbnb in Broad Ripple – Broad Ripple Burrow

This homely, super cozy bungalow comes with two bedrooms so families can enjoy some space. There is a fenced in rear garden, perfect for children to play safely in.

The kitchen is fully equipped with everything you could need – including a coffee grinder. The warm hosts provide a welcome basket.

Best Hotel in Broad Ripple – Hotel Broad Ripple

Hotel Broad Ripple offers spacious, immaculately presented bedrooms and private bathrooms. Kitchens are available in most units and the hotel comes with ample outdoor spaces to relax.

There is even a Jacuzzi. Larger families can opt to book a Family Cottage or Family Apartment. A short walk to the river.

FAQ about Finding a Place to Stay in Indianapolis

Here’s what people usually ask us about the areas of Indianapolis and where to stay.

Final thoughts on where to stay in Indianapolis

Charming, cool and with heaps to reel its visitors in, it’s no surprise that Indianapolis has flourished as a burgeoning tourist destination over recent years.

With its stunning historic architecture, ample green spaces, a booming culinary and craft beverage scene and not to mention lively nightlife to boot, there’s really something for everyone in Indianapolis.

Also, the Hoosiers are extremely friendly!

To recap our guide, we recommend Lockerbie Square as the best neighborhood to stay in Indianapolis. There is heaps to do, it’s a stone’s throw from Mile Square, it’s visually stunning, and the hotel prices won’t hit your vacation budget too hard.

Check out our top pick, the Nestle Inn, for the best Indianapolis accommodation.

And don’t forget to take out Travel Insurance for your trip! I have been using World Nomads for some time now and made a few claims over the years. They’re easy to use, professional and relatively affordable. They may also let you buy or extend a policy once you’ve started your trip and are already abroad which is super handy.

Getting an estimate from World Nomads is simple – just click the button or image below, fill out the necessary info, and you’re on your way!

world nomads insurance banner

Do you own an awesome hostel, hotel or apartment? Want to be featured in our list? Email [email protected] to find out how.


Find out how YOU can support the site.

We work hard to put out the best backpacker resources on the web for free! It’s all about helping out our tribe of awesome backpacker readers (that’s you!). Please visit the link to find out how you can help keep the site going 🙂

For the sake of transparency, some of the links in our content are affiliate links. This means that if you book your accommodation, buy a piece of gear, or sort your insurance through our link, we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only link to stuff that members of the Broke Backpacker team has actually used and never endorse products or services that are not up to scratch. Thanks for your support!