If you’re looking for an idyllic New Jersey coastal town to enjoy, you’ll adore Cape May. It’s situated on the tip of the Cape May Peninsula and boasts beautiful beaches along the coastline. Not to mention the gorgeous Victorian architecture of the hotels and shops along Washington Street Mall, and plenty of incredible restaurants.
It’s fair to say that Cape May gets pretty popular during the warmer months. So much so, that its population grows by over 50,000 during the summer! I recommend visiting outside of the off season to lower the average price of your accomodation and the crowds will be waaaaay less too.
Cape May is also one of America’s oldest tourist destinations and rightly so. Aside from the beautiful architecture, Cape May has plenty of wonderful nature on offer. You can enjoy the ocean views while you scour the beach for the famous Cape May diamonds and you might even spot whales on migration!
With over 400 bird species on record of being spotted here, Cape May is renowned for bird watching, especially in the fall. Make sure you keep an eye out for these too.
Finding where to stay in the Cape can be pretty overwhelming. To help you out, I’ve figured out the very best accommodations and listed them all below!
Photo: @danielle_wyatt
- Where is the Best Place to Stay in Cape May?
- Cape May Neighborhood Guide – Best Places to Stay in Cape May
- Cape May’s Three Best Neighborhoods to Stay in
- FAQs About Finding a Place to Stay in Cape May
- What To Pack For Cape May
- Don’t Forget Travel Insurance for Cape May
- Final Thoughts on Where to Stay in Cape May
Soaking up the sun in beach shacks as you spend time Backpacking around America is becoming more and more popular and Cape May has plenty to offer. Not only the beach, but the historic district, Washington Street Mall, and the beautiful gardens of Madison Avenue are a must, in my opinion. An original tourist destination, the options for accommodation are abundant.
With such a longstanding history, hotels in Cape May are so plentiful, that it’s hard to narrow it down. Nonetheless, here are my top picks. That being said, I’m sure there’s something for everyone’s travel style in this article so please, read on, you!
ICONA Cape May | Best Hotel in Cape May
ICONA Cape May is a beautiful Cape May Beachfront hotel with everything you could want from a coastal vacation in the sunshine. You’ll get superb amenities, a great location, and best of all – you’re right next to the beach! Enjoy the full hotel experience with their shuttle service, room service, and heated pool.
Marquis De Lafayette Hotel | Best Seaside Resort in Cape May
Located on Beach Avenue, the Marquis De Lafayette Hotel is the best hotel in this central location. Walking distance to Washington Street Mall, you can go from beach club to nostalgic historic boutique shopping and back to the beach again to your heart’s content! Make the most of the historic district on the back doorstep of your hotel in this great seaside location in Cape May.
The Marquis De Lafayette hotel is one of the best for listening to live music at their beach bar.
The Jetty Motel | Best Budget Accommodation in Cape May
This budget motel is in the heart of West Cape May, just a five-minute walk from the beaches. It’s close to other natural attractions as well, making it ideal for a family trip.
Rooms are simple but comfy, with all the basic amenities. There’s even a pool onsite, suitable for all ages.
Heart of Cape May | Best Airbnb in Cape May
Stay at this tidy condo in the heart of Cape May’s beachfront area and enjoy walking to your heart’s content. Walking distance to the beach, this apartment is nestled in a great location central to all amenities of Cape May, including Washington Street Mall. A great alternative to hotels in Cape May, this apartment has one bedroom but can sleep up to four with a pullout couch in the lounge.
Cape May’s Beachfront
If you’re looking for the ideal Cape May destination to spend your first time in the area, you’ll adore Cape May’s Beachfront because it offers the perfect location. You’ll always be close to the best sites, and you’re only a minute or two from the beaches.
Wildwood Crest
The area is home to Cape May’s most extensive selection of restaurants, bars, and nightlife opportunities, with a superb range of beaches. If you’re bringing Fido along, you’ll adore the Wildwood Dog Park & Beach – it’s the perfect place for your furry friend!
West Cape May
West Cape May is ideal for families because there are many things to do. It is far quieter than many other places just a short distance away. If you would love to see a great green space where your family can relax, play, and sit on the floor, West Cape May offers the ultimate spot for your family.
Cape May’s Three Best Neighborhoods to Stay in
Cape May is the OG seaside destination in New Jersey. If you’re dreaming of beaches, quaint shops, and waterside restaurants along Beach Avenue, then you really can’t go wrong. There are so many things to do in Cape May, so you’ll have endless entertainment during your stay.
If you’re visiting Cape May for the first time, you’ll undoubtedly want to stay on Cape May’s Beachfront. Famed for its gorgeous views, historical sights, and stunning beaches, there are loads of attractions here to help you get to know the area. These include the Cape May Rotary Park and the Colonial House Museum.
Beach Avenue is the strip for hotels in Cape May with ocean views. I’ve included my favorites below, the Icona Cape May as well as the Marquis de Lafayette Hotel. The Mahalo is a sweet alternative, offering townhouse accommodation.
Wildwood Crest is the best place for budget backpackers visiting Cape May. It’s full of little shops and restaurants, and you can still enjoy kilometers of beach without breaking the bank. Wildwood is the ultimate retreat from the Big Apple, and its low prices make it a great place to stop off on a road trip around New Jersey.
Photo: @amandaadraper
West Cape May is the ultimate Cape May area if you’re looking to stay somewhere quieter and more rural. Although it’s slightly away from the main highlights, you can still take a short walk or bike ride into Cape May’s center or the beach. The area is surrounded by peaceful woodland and nature to explore, and its quiet ambiance makes it my top pick for families.
Aside from the beach, the Strawberry Festival, the Bean Festival, and a variety of popular antique shows draw visitors to Cape May. Don’t miss the boutique shopping at Washington Street Mall or roaming the gardens at Madison Avenue. You’ll also find multiple historic homes that are perfect for those looking to take stunning photographs of the Cape!
If you’re still unsure where to stay in Cape May, New Jersey – no worries! Read on for more detailed info on each place below and let me guide you through the top accommodations and things to do.
1. Cape May’s Beachfront – Where to Stay in Cape May for your First Time
The Beachfront is the best place to go if you’re looking for the ideal location for your first time in the area. Wherever you are in this area, you’ll always be close to ocean views and a minute or two from the beaches. If you’re looking for tasty international cuisine, you’ll find plenty of options here, too.
Cape May’s Beachfront also has a diverse range of accommodations. With an eclectic mixture of hotels, guesthouses, apartments, and Airbnb’s with stunning Atlantic Ocean views, you’ll be spoilt for choice!
Beyond the beachfront is lots to explore. Cape May is famous for its Victorian architecture, from shops in Washington Street Mall to the decor in Congress Hall. If nature is more your thing, be sure to get amongst the boat tours or take a walk through Madison Avenue.
Congress Hall | Best Hotel in Cape May’s Beachfront
Stay at America’s first seaside resort in Cape May. Congress Hall sits in a great location, with everything you could need. From an in-house spa to restaurants and cafes to an outdoor pool.
If you feel like popping down to visit Cape Beach’s ocean views, Congress Hall has cabana tents within walking distance from the hotel. The hotel’s private beach area is perfect for enjoying the beach with fewer crowds.
La Mer Beachfront Resort | Best Resort in Cape May’s Beachfront
This resort boasts a superb waterfront location, right next to Washington Street and Cape May city center. You’ll be in the heart of all the action, helping you make the most of your trip.
This hotel offers a vast range of superb amenities, including a fitness center, a bar, and an outdoor pool.
Mahalo Cape May | Best Apartment in Cape May’s Beachfront
Mahalo Cape May is a newly renovated townhouse accommodation on the beachfront of Cape May. Offering an epic beach service, you will feel well looked after during your vacation. Midway along Beach Avenue, Mahalo Cape is neighbored by some great restaurants, or make yourself at home and use their full kitchen.
I recommend taking a walk down to Madison Avenue to enjoy the gardens and taking advantage of their shuttle service to return home. No one likes to worry about parking on holiday!
Heart of Cape May | Best Airbnb in Cape May’s Beachfront
Stay at this tidy condo in the heart of Cape May’s beachfront area and enjoy walking to your heart’s content. Walking distance to the beach, this apartment is nestled in a great location central to all amenities of Cape May, including Washington Street Mall. A great alternative to hotels in Cape May, this apartment has one bedroom but can sleep up to four with a pullout couch in the lounge.
Things to See and Do in Cape May’s Beachfront:
- Walk straight out of your accommodation and onto the gorgeous beaches.
- Find secret spots in a Cape May Scavenger Hunt.
- Visit Splash Zone Water, where you’ll find slides, on-site restaurants, and a lazy river.
- See Cape May from the Sea on a Sunset Dinner Cruise on the Spirit of Cape May
- Book a Private Yoga Session on the Beach with Kelsey
- Walk out to explore the iconic Cape May Lighthouse, or discover the rich history of New Jersey’s nine lighthouses on this incredible sightseeing cruise.
- Mix activity with leisure with Cape May Cycle Cruises.
We’ve tested countless backpacks over the years, but there’s one that has always been the best and remains the best buy for adventurers: the broke backpacker-approved Osprey Aether and Ariel series.
Want more deetz on why these packs are so damn perfect? Then read our comprehensive review for the inside scoop!
View on Osprey View on REI2. Wildwood Crest – Best Place to Stay in Cape May on a Budget
Wildwood Crest is where the fun happens in Cape May. There’s a vast array of ocean views, beach, and accommodations here, with fewer crowds and plenty of options fit for budget backpackers.
The area is home to Cape May’s most extensive selection of restaurants, bars, and nightlife opportunities, with a superb range of beaches. If you’re bringing Fido along, you’ll adore the Wildwood Dog Park & Beach – it’s the perfect place for your furry friend!
Starlux Hotel | Best Hotel in Wildwood Crest
The Wildwood Crest Starlux Hotel is a fantastic option for all budget travelers out there. Not only do you get an affordable price, but you also get a superb, central location. You’ll be next to the beach and all of the magnificent nearby attractions that make Wildwood Crest such a popular destination for anyone visiting the USA.
Shalimar Resort | Best Resort in Wildwood Crest
The Shalimar Resort provides a vast array of resort facilities and a prime location in Wildwood Crest. Rooms are comfortable, and there are BBQ facilities on-site.
You’re only 100 yards from the gorgeous beach and a two-minute walk from the buzz and excitement of Centennial Park. Morey’s Piers Amusement Park is only 1.6 miles away.
Salty Shore Retreat | Best Airbnb in Wildwood Crest
The Salty Shore Retreat is the best budget Airbnb option in Wildwood Crest. In a great location within walking distance of the beach with a lower-than-average price tag. The ultimate crash pad, this Airbnb has a pull-out couch for sleeping when you’re done with all your beach activities.
The local amusement parks are under two miles away, just a short walk, cycle, or ride on public transport.
Things to See and Do in Wildwood Crest:
- Head to Morey’s Piers, home to excellent roller coasters, gardens, and a water park.
- Swap a beachwalk for the Boardwalk where you’ll find lots of superb entertainment. Take a photo at the iconic Wildwoods Beach Ball Sign.
- Explore the Raging Waters Water Park, where visitors enjoy the incredible swimming pools, water slides, and places to relax.
- Take a journey to the Historic Cold Spring Village, an area with a history dating between 1789 to 1840.
- Venture across the peninsular to Create Coastal Seaglass Art
- Enjoy the incredible Great White 1996, one of the most iconic roller coasters in the area.
- Visit the local Wildwood Historical Society, a superb museum with lots of vintage photos and memorabilia.
3. West Cape May – Best Neighborhood in Cape May for Families to Stay In
West Cape May is ideal for families because there are so many things to do. It’s far quieter than the surrounding areas, but close enough so you can explore easily. It’s full of green spaces and plenty of areas to run around. Willow Creek Winery is a wonderful option for lunch or one of their fire pit evenings.
West Cape May is close to the beaches, too. You’ll have multiple options at hand, and the area is a mere five minutes from Cape May Public Beach!
Seaside Escape | Best Apartment in West Cape May
The Seaside Escape apartment in West Cape May is ideal for families. It’s surrounded by nature and close to the delightful beaches of Wildwood Crest. A 10-minute drive will get you to Cape May’s best restaurants, hotels, and waterparks!
Visitors are only five minutes from the local Cape May winery, where you can try a whole bunch of superb local wine! In my view, that lands this apartment in a great location!
Wilbraham Mansion | Best Bed and Breakfast in West Cape May
The Wilbraham Mansion is a terrific option for families in West Cape May because it offers an indoor pool, great amenities, and a superb location.
The B&B is neatly placed between West Cape May’s superb nature and winery. Plus, it’s right next to the attractions of Cape’s May’s beachfront areas.
The Jetty Motel | Best Motel in West Cape May
This budget motel is in the heart of West Cape May, just a five-minute walk from the beaches. It’s close to other natural attractions as well, making it ideal for a family trip.
Rooms are simple but comfy, with all the basic amenities. There’s even a pool onsite, suitable for all ages.
Things to See and Do in West Cape May:
- Explore the nearby Beach Plum Farm, offering visitors a fantastic insight into the local farming industry. It’s home to over 100 fruit varieties, flowers, herbs, and various vegetables.
- Check out the Cape May Market, where you’ll find superb locally sourced products.
- Explore the Flying Fish Studio, where you’ll find endless knowledge and a vast array of clothing.
- Grab a bike from Cape Island Bike Rentals and whizz around the stunning coastal locations, historical areas and hotels in Cape May.
- Take a 10-minute walk to the stunning beaches of Cape May’s Beachfront and Wildwood Crest.
- Head out to enjoy one of the fire pits at Willow Creek Winery.
Stash your cash safely with this money belt. It will keep your valuables safely concealed, no matter where you go.
It looks exactly like a normal belt except for a SECRET interior pocket perfectly designed to hide a wad of cash, a passport photocopy or anything else you may wish to hide. Never get caught with your pants down again! (Unless you want to…)
Hide Yo’ Money!FAQs About Finding a Place to Stay in Cape May
Here’s what people usually ask me about the areas of Cape May and where to stay.
What To Pack For Cape May
Pants, socks, underwear, soap?! Take it from me, packing for a hostel stay is not always quite as straightforward as it seems. Working out what to bring and what to leave at home is an art I have perfected over many years.
Ear Plugs
Snoring dorm-mates can ruin your nights rest and seriously damage the hostel experience. This is why I always travel with a pack of decent ear plugs.
Hanging Laundry Bag
Trust us, this is an absolute game changer. Super compact, a hanging mesh laundry bag stops your dirty clothes from stinking, you don’t know how much you need one of these… so just get it, thank us later.
Sea To Summit Micro Towel
Hostel towels are scummy and take forever to dry. Microfibre towels dry quickly, are compact, lightweight, and can be used as a blanket or yoga mat if need be.
Monopoly Deal
Forget about Poker! Monopoly Deal is the single best travel card game that we have ever played. Works with 2-5 players and guarantees happy days.
Grayl Geopress Water Bottle
Always travel with a water bottle! They save you money and reduce your plastic footprint on our planet. The Grayl Geopress acts as a purifier AND temperature regulator. Boom!
Check out my definitive Hotel Packing list for even more top packing tips!
Is Cape May on the Jersey Shore?
Yes! Technically, Cape May is on the Jersey Shore. But it’s the antithesis of the Jersey Shore you’ll see on TV. Swap out nightclubs and tanning parlors for afternoon tea at Victorian mansions and ocean views including a famous lighthouse.
What’s with the Victorian Architecture?
The city was inspired by gingerbread houses!
Haha, no, Cape May is one of America’s oldest seaside resort tourist destinations. Ergo the plethora of Victorian inspired hotels with ocean views. Congress Hall is one of the OG hotels Cape May has on offer, originally a wooden building built by the beach in 1816. A popular vacation destination for the presidents of the US, Congress Hall underwent a full renovation lasting seven years, completed in 2002.
Is there hidden treasure in Cape May?
Ooh, do you think I’d tell you if I knew?! Legend has it that pirate Captain William Kidd left buried treasure somewhere in Cape May. Channel your inner adventurer and turn your beach holiday into a treasure hunt. Who knows what you might find…
Don’t Forget Travel Insurance for Cape May
ALWAYS sort out your backpacker insurance before your trip. There’s plenty to choose from in that department, but a good place to start is Safety Wing.
They offer month-to-month payments, no lock-in contracts, and require absolutely no itineraries: that’s the exact kind of insurance long-term travellers and digital nomads need.
SafetyWing is cheap, easy, and admin-free: just sign up lickety-split so you can get back to it!
Click the button below to learn more about SafetyWing’s setup or read our insider review for the full tasty scoop.
Final Thoughts on Where to Stay in Cape May
Cape May is one of America’s oldest and most popular tourist destinations – for good reason. That’s why there are endless accommodation options and activities for people of all age groups.
If you’re staying anywhere near New York, or are visiting from further afield, Cape May provides the ultimate beach break. There’s so much to see and do here, so you can make it as laid-back or as action-packed as you please!
If you choose any of the excellent accommodation options above, you’ll have a terrific time on your beautiful summer vacation escape.
- Check out our ultimate guide backpacking around USA.
- Figured out where you wanna stay? Now it’s time to pick the perfect hostel in USA.
- Or… maybe you want to check out some Airbnbs in USA instead.
- Next up you’re gonna need to know all the best places to visit in USA to plan your trip.
- Save yourself hassle and money and get an international sim card for USA.
- Swing by our super epic backpacking packing list to prep for your trip.
Photo: Roaming Ralph
