Nestled at the end of New York’s Long Island, Montauk is a spectacular holiday destination that offers expansive parks, beautiful beaches, and plenty of relaxing sea breezes.

But with beauty comes costs – and Montauk is certainly not cheap! That’s exactly why we made this guide for where to stay in Montauk.

Written by our expert travel guides, this article breaks down the different areas of Montauk by category, so you’ll know exactly where to stay based on your needs and interests.

So whether you’re looking for a romantic getaway for two, a beach vacay with friends, or a relaxing holiday with the kids, our guide will show you everything you need to know – plus a few hidden gems.

So without further ado, here’s our guide for where to stay in Montauk, New York.

Where to Stay in Montauk

Looking for a specific place to stay? These are our highest recommendations for places to stay in Montauk.

Remade Fishermans Home: Chilled out cottage near the strip

Chilled out cottage near the strip

If you’re planning on making the most of Mountak’s generous offering of bars and restaurants, this place wouldn’t be a bad call. Kirk’s Park is a pretty bustling area during the day. This cottage has a lot of space, making it ideal for a group or for hosting.

Best House in Montauk Village: Cute Home close to Central Village

Cute Home close to Central Village

Located super conveniently, this cozy house is the perfect place to stay if you’re visiting Montauk for the first time. You’ll be in walking distance to the village centre, the beach and most hotspots of the area. You can chill in your garden during the day and fire up the BBQ in the evening. The house sleeps 6 people, so it’s ideal for a group of friends or small families as well. It was recently renovated, so you can enjoy high-quality amenities and a brand-new home!

Best Motel in Montauk: Daunts Albatross Motel

Daunts Albatross Motel

If you’re hoping to explore Montauk on a budget, this is your best bet for accommodations. Set in central Montauk, this motel has a great location and clean rooms. It is within walking distance of the beach and there are plenty of restaurants and shops nearby.

Montauk Neighborhood Guide

FIRST TIME IN MONTAUK
Montauk Village, Mountauk
FIRST TIME IN MONTAUK

Montauk Village

If you’re visiting Montauk for the first time there’s no better place to stay than Montauk Village. Located at the heart of the hamlet Montauk Village is a buzzing holiday destination with restaurants, shops, bars and beaches. It’s great for anyone looking to lounge on the beach and enjoy a quintessential American summer holiday.

ON A BUDGET
Montauk Village, Montauk
ON A BUDGET

Montauk Village

Montauk Village is the heart and soul of the hamlet. It’s where you’ll find restaurants and shops, as well as pristine beaches and buzzing bars. This popular holiday destination attracts thousands of people each year to enjoy its beautiful views and relaxed atmosphere.

NIGHTLIFE
Kirk Park, Montauk
NIGHTLIFE

Kirk Park

Kirk Park is a low-key beach located just outside of the centre of Montauk. It draws a diverse crowd of locals, tourists and the occasional celebrity to enjoy its white sand beach and stunning Atlantic views.

COOLEST PLACE TO STAY
Ditch Plains, Montauk
COOLEST PLACE TO STAY

Ditch Plains

Ditch Plains is a fantastic beach located at the east end of Montauk. Its remote location on the island, away from the hustle and bustle of central Montauk, gives this stretch of sand a quiet and peaceful atmosphere. It’s here that you can enjoy a relaxing day of lounging on the sand and staring off into space.

FOR FAMILIES
Gin Beach, Montauk
FOR FAMILIES

Gin Beach

Gin Beach is a beautiful beach located north of central Montauk. Separated from the rest of the city by Lake Montauk, Gin Beach has a calm and relaxing atmosphere that’s perfect for holiday travellers.

Montauk is a popular holiday destination located in northeastern New York. It is one of the five hamlets of East Hampton and is most famous for its stunning white sand beaches and its relaxed atmosphere.

Known to many New York residents as “The End,’ Montauk occupies the easternmost point of Long Island. It is home to six lush and expansive state parks, as well as one of the largest commercial and recreational fishing fleets in the state of New York.

There’s plenty to see and do in Montauk, from lounging on the beach and surfing the waves to enjoying fresh seafood and visiting historic sights. To help you plan your trip to Montauk, this guide will highlight the “can’t miss” activities and attractions by interest and area.

Montauk Village sits at the heart of the region. It is a small and charming town with plenty of shops, restaurants and bars.

Directly south of Montauk Village is Kirk Park Beach. A lively and vibrant area, Kirk Park is where you’ll find a good mix of bars, cafes and restaurants.

Head east from here you’ll arrive in Ditch Plains Beach. An oft-overlooked part of the hamlet, Ditch Plains is where you’ll find stunning natural scenery, a beautiful beach and some of the best waves in New York.

And finally, Gin Beach is a beautiful and relaxing stretch of sand located on the northern shores of Long Island. It’s a kid-friendly beach with gentle waves an is ideal for a day of building sandcastles and basking in the sun.

Still not sure where to stay in Montauk? Don’t worry, we’ve got you covered!

The BEST Travel Backpack?!

Pssssst! Not picked the perfect travel backpack yet? The Broke Backpacker team has tried out over thirty backpacks this year! Our favourite travel backpack is the Osprey Aether (comes in 55 – 85 litre sizes).

View on Osprey View on REI

Montauk’s 5 Best Neighborhoods to Stay in

In this next section, we’ll take a look in detail at the best places to stay in Montauk. Each is a little different from the last, so be sure to read each section carefully and pick the neighbourhood that’s right for you!

1. Montauk Village – Where to stay in Montauk first time

If you’re visiting Montauk for the first time there’s no better place to stay than Montauk Village. Located at the heart of the hamlet Montauk Village is a buzzing holiday destination with restaurants, shops, bars and beaches. It’s great for anyone looking to lounge on the beach and enjoy a quintessential American summer holiday.

Montauk Village makes an excellent base for exploring the Hamptons. From here, you can easily visit six state parks and enjoy a vast network of hiking, biking and cycling trails.

Looking for a more relaxing holiday? Grab your towel and head to nearby Kirk Park Beach where you can bask in the sunshine, stunning views, and refreshing sea breezes.

Montauk Village, Mountauk

Things to See and Do in Montauk Village

  • Eat fresh and delicious seafood at Backyard Restaurant.
  • Enjoy an incredible meal and an unforgettable sunset at Navy Beach.
  • Dive deep into the history of Montauk at the Second House Museum.
  • Explore the grounds of beautiful Hither Hills State Park.
  • Play around of 18 holes at the Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course.
  • Dine on exquisite seafood dishes at Surfside Inn.
  • Feast on tasty American fare at Ruschmeyer’s Restaurant.
  • Kickstart your day with a satisfying breakfast or brunch at ALL DAY at Breakers
  • Head to nearby Kirk Park Beach and spend a day relaxing at the beach.

Lovely Montauk Bungalow: Cosy apartment with an ocean view

Cosy apartment with an ocean view

Bring the local calming atmosphere into your home with this cost little chalet. With its log burning fire and ocean views, its the perfect spot to unwind for a few days. It’s just outside the heart of Montauk village, so you’ll be getting a healthy dose of privacy without sacrificing much in return.

Best Budget Option: Sea-Sational Ditch Plains Salty Air Cottage

Sea Sational Ditch Plains Salty Air Cottage

Breakers at the Ocean is a delightful three-star motel in central Montauk. It’s within walking distance of the beach as well as great restaurants and lively bars. This motel boasts 20 clean and spacious rooms with modern amenities. You’ll have access to a private beach and an outdoor pool.

Best House in Montauk Village: Cute Home close to Central Village

Cute Home close to Central Village

Located super conveniently, this cozy house is the perfect place to stay if you’re visiting Montauk for the first time. You’ll be in walking distance to the village centre, the beach and most hotspots of the area. You can chill in your garden during the day and fire up the BBQ in the evening. The house sleeps 6 people, so it’s ideal for a group of friends or small families as well. It was recently renovated, so you can enjoy high-quality amenities and a brand-new home!

Best Resort in Montauk Village: Beach Plum Resort

Beach Plum Resort

This is one of the most affordable options in Montauk Village. You’ll enjoy modern facilities such as an outdoor swimming pool and free wifi. This resort has 29 bright and comfortable beds, as well as a relaxing garden. It’s also ideally located for exploring Montauk on foot or by car.

2. Montauk Village – Where to stay in Montauk on a budget

Montauk Village is the heart and soul of the hamlet. It’s where you’ll find restaurants and shops, as well as pristine beaches and buzzing bars. This popular holiday destination attracts thousands of people each year to enjoy its beautiful views and relaxed atmosphere.

It’s also where you’ll find the best options for affordable accommodations in Montauk. Now, it is worth noting that Montauk is an incredibly expensive holiday destination, and budget accommodations are hard to come by. Although you won’t find any backpacker hostels in the area, there are a handful of motels that offer a financial break from the high-end hotels and oceanside resorts.

Montauk Village, Montauk
|source: Chris Ferrara (shutterstock)

Things to See and Do in Montauk Village

  • Lace up your shoes and spend a day exploring charming Hopping Frog Pond.
  • Grab a rod and cast a line off Navy Beach Pier. If fishing’s not your thing, you can always just enjoy the view.
  • Explore the grounds of the Hither Woods Preserve that has trails, a sandy beach, and plenty of picturesque picnic spots.
  • Go for a stroll at Fort Pond Bay Park.
  • Rent a paddleboard and glide across the water at Navy Road Park.
  • Dig into a delicious plate of Belgian waffles at Bex Waffles.
  • Sink your teeth into a hot and savour slice at Pizza Village.

Stunning Apartment in Montauk Village: Boho Bayfront Artist’s Condo

Boho Bayfront Artists Condo

Montauk definitely isn’t the cheapest, however, there are a few hacks on how to save some money. If you’re choosing to stay at this stunning condo, just bring two friends with you and split the costs at the end. You’re promised amazing views from your private balcony and a charming artist home that has been designed with an eye for detail. With it’s super homely and welcoming vibes, you’ll feel like you’re at home straight away.

Private Room With Pool: Montauk Pool, Hot tub, Peloton bike, private

Montauk Pool Hot tub Peloton bike private

Renting out an entire pad in Montauk is expensive. If you don’t have the brass for that then check out this well priced private room near Montauk village. It has it’s own entrance and bathroom so you still get that much needed privacy. Perhaps best of all though, you can also use the swimming pool, peloton bike and the hot tub!

Best Motel in Montauk Village: Daunts Albatross Motel

Daunts Albatross Motel

The Daunts Albatross Motel is our pick for where to stay in Montauk Village if you’re on a budget. Set in central Montauk, this motel has a great location and clean rooms. It is within walking distance of the beach, restaurants and lots of shops. There’s also a swimming pool and laundry facilities.

3. Kirk Park – Best area to stay in Montauk for nightlife

Kirk Park is a low-key beach located just outside of the centre of Montauk. It draws a diverse crowd of locals, tourists and the occasional celebrity to enjoy its white sand beach and stunning Atlantic views.

This bustling and lively area is also our pick for where to stay if you’re looking for nightlife in Montauk. Just a short walk from the beach is a vast array of bars, restaurants and pubs serving up good drinks, upbeat music and a whole host of great times.

Love to eat? Kirk Park is for you! This beachside neighbourhood is home to a myriad of cafes and eateries that offer delicious seafood and dishes from cuisines from around the world.

Kirk Park, Montauk

Things to See and Do in Kirk Park

  • Eat seafood at Harvest On Fort Pond.
  • Satisfy your sweet tooth at Mr John’s Pancake House.
  • Sip refreshing cocktails at The Point.
  • Indulge at the Montauk Bake Shop.
  • Enjoy a delicious meal at The Muse at the End.
  • Sample a few beers at Montauk Brewing Company.
  • Feast on American fare at Shagwong.
  • Kickstart your day with a filling breakfast at Joni’s.
  • Spend the night at The Sloppy Tuna.
  • Try the white wine mussels at 668 The Gigshack.
  • Party well into the night at The Montauk Beach House.
  • Rub elbows with celebrities at The Surf Lodge.

Remade Fishermans Home: Chilled out cottage near the strip

Chilled out cottage near the strip

If you’re planning on making the most of Mountak’s generous offering of bars and restaurants, this place wouldn’t be a bad call. Kirk’s Park is a pretty bustling area during the day. This cottage has a lot of space, making it ideal for a group or for hosting.

Best House in Kirk Park: Oceanfront Home in Downtown Montauk

Oceanfront Home in Downtown Montauk

Being in the best area for nightlife is one thing, but staying right in front of the ocean is luxury on a completely different level! This amazing beachfront house couldn’t be in a better location – only a few minutes from Kirk Beach, but far enough from the buzz to enjoy a good nights sleep. If you you and your friends want to explore Montauk’s nightlife, there’s no better option than this massive 3-bedroom beach house!

Best Guesthouse in Kirk Park: Steps from the Ocean

Steps from the Ocean

Want to be as close to the beach as possible? This stunning home is the right place for you. Sleeping up to 12 people, it’s ideal for big families or a group of friends. You’ll be in a beachfront location, meaning that you just need to step out of the front door and you’ll feel the sand under your feet. Regarding the price, it’s definitely not the cheapest place, but if you split the bill at the end, everyone gets a slice of super affordable luxury and a great trip experience.

Best Resort in Kirk Park: Ocean Resort Inn

Ocean Resort Inn

This peaceful three-star resort is our recommendation for where to stay in Kirk Park. It’s located near the heart of Montauk and there are bistros, bars and shops on its doorsteps. You’ll enjoy bright rooms with kitchenettes, cable TV and microwaves. There’s also a pool and bike rental service.

Need some extra energy?
Power Adapter

One of the best investments you can make is a worldwide travel adapter that will work anywhere! The one featured here is tough, reliable and a solid buy – Don’t leave home without one.

Buy your travel adapter on Amazon now.

4. Ditch Plains – Coolest place to stay in Montauk

Ditch Plains is a fantastic beach located at the east end of Montauk. Its remote location on the island, away from the hustle and bustle of central Montauk, gives this stretch of sand a quiet and peaceful atmosphere. It’s here that you can enjoy a relaxing day of lounging on the sand and staring off into space.

Situated at the tip of the South Fork, Ditch Plains is also where you’ll find some of the best waves for surfing. Whether you’re a newbie or a novice, you’ll have so much fun grabbing a board and crashing through these near-perfect waves. That’s why Ditch Plains gets our vote for the coolest neighbourhood in Montauk.

Ditch Plains, Montauk
|source: Gjorcheski (shutterstock)

Things to See and Do in Ditch Plains

  • Visit the Ditch Witch food truck and snack on everything from delicious burrito to cinnamon buns!
  • Learn to hang ten by signing up for Surf Camp Lessons.
  • Enjoy the views as you hike the easy clifftop walk at Shadmoor State Park.
  • Take a stroll through Rheinstein Estate Park.
  • Eat creative and delicious dishes at The Crow’s Nest.
  • Hike through the woods and onto the beach at Amsterdam Beach State Park.
  • Rent a board and hit the waves.
  • Grab a towel and spend a day lounging on the sands at Ditch Plains Beach.

Epic Hotel in Ditch Plains: The Crow’s Nest Inn

The Crows Nest Inn

This is one of the best places to stay in Ditch Plains thanks to its comfortable beds and excellent location near the beach. It offers cosy rooms that are outfitted with modern amenities to suit any and all travellers. You’ll also enjoy free wifi throughout your stay.

Charming Home in Ditch Plains: Cute Beach House

Cute Beach House

This amazing home is a bit more affordable than the others on the list. but that doesn’t mean that it’s lacking any value. The charming beach house is just a couple of minutes from the sea and located in a quiet neighborhood. You can enjoy your morning coffee on your private terrace and relax before you head out to explore Montauk. The hosts are known to be incredibly kind and always ready for help and great recommendations.

Best Villa in Ditch Plains: Upscale Montauk Villa

Upscale Montauk Villa

Looking for some luxury? Stop right here, we’ve got the perfect place for you. This stunning upscale villa is a real treat. The super bright living area is only being topped with the private hot tub on your massive patio. Invite your friends over for a BBQ party and fire up the grill. The beach is in short walking distance as well. If you’re travelling with your four-legged friend, you’ll be pleased to know that this place is pet friendly too.

5. Culloden Point – Best neighbourhood in Montauk for families

Gin Beach is a beautiful beach located north of central Montauk. Separated from the rest of the city by Lake Montauk, Culloden has a calm and relaxing atmosphere that’s perfect for holiday travellers.

Our pick for where to stay in Montauk for families, Culloden point is a kid-friendly area. The beach is composed of soft golden sand and gentle waves lap the shoreline. Here, your little ones can run, jump, laugh and play in a safe and clean environment.

Gin Beach is also an ideal base for anyone looking to get back to nature. Surrounded by Montauk Point State Park, Gin Beach is in close proximity to a myriad of hiking, biking and trekking trails.

Gin Beach, Montauk

Things to See and Do in Culloden Point

  • Hike out to the Historic Montauk Lighthouse, which was built in 1796 under the authorization of President George Washington.
  • Shop for snacks and tasty treats at the Gin Beach Market.
  • Eat casual seafood and classic American fare at Rick’s Crabby Cowboy Café.
  • Satisfy your sweet tooth with a cone of delicious ice cream at Ben & Jerry’s.
  • Dine on fresh seafood at Gosman’s.
  • Sip a cold beer and enjoy a good meal at The Dock Bar & Grill.
  • Trek the trails and enjoy amazing views at Montauk Point State Park.

Ocean Front Resort: Open plan studio suited to a family getaway

Open plan studio suited to a family getaway

If you’re looking to treat the entire family to some sun, sea, and waves, you could do a lot worse than this. It’s in an ideal location for both the beach and the villages great range of cafe’s and restaurants.

Whole Apartment With Killer View: Coastline View Studio

Coastline View Studio

This sun drenched studio apartment is perfect for families, couples or friends looking to get away and discover Montauk! Be one of the first guests to enjoy high quality linens, super fast wifi and cable TV! Located in Sun & Sound Resort in Montauk’s famed harbor district. This unit is perfectly located to experience all that Montauk has to offer…

Sit back on the balcony and enjoy glass of wine as the sun sets perfectly over Culloden Point.

Best House in Culloden Point: Family Beachhouse in Safe Location

Family Beachhouse in Safe Location

Travelling with your family doesn’t have to be stressful. This amazing beach house accommodates up to 6 people, offering enough space for even slightly bigger groups. Located close to the beach, it’s only a short walk from your doorstep until you can feel the sand under your feet. The hosts are known for going above and beyond for their guests, so you can be sure that you and your family are being taken care of to the absolute max!

Best Resort in Culloden Point: Sun and Sound Montauk

Sun and Sound Montauk

This is our top recommendation for where to stay in Gin Beach. This comfortable resort provides clean rooms with kitchenettes and a range of necessities. Ideally located in Montauk, this resort is just steps from the beach, delicious restaurants and plenty of tourist attractions.

Final Thoughts on Where to Stay in Montauk

Montauk is a venerable holiday destination that attracts thousands of visitors every year. It has stunning golden sand beaches, lush state parks, and a myriad of fun and funky seafood shacks and beachside bars.

In this guide, we’ve looked at the best places to stay in Montauk. It is, unfortunately, a very expensive place to stay and there aren’t any hostels, but we’ve done our best to include affordable motel and hotel options, alongside some more luxurious accommodations.

If you’re still not sure where to stay in Montauk, here’s a quick recap of our favourites.

Daunts Albatross Motel is the most affordable option in Montauk. It has a great central location, clean rooms and is within walking distance of the beach and a lot of restaurants.

Ocean Resort Inn in Kirk Park is our favourite hotel. It has bright and well-equipped rooms, and you’ll have access to a pool and bike rentals.

And don’t forget to take out Travel Insurance for your trip! I have been using World Nomads for some time now and made a few claims over the years. They’re easy to use, professional and relatively affordable. They may also let you buy or extend a policy once you’ve started your trip and are already abroad which is super handy.

Getting an estimate from World Nomads is simple – just click the button or image below, fill out the necessary info, and you’re on your way!

world nomads insurance banner

Do you own an awesome hostel, hotel or apartment? Want to be featured in our list? Email [email protected] to find out how.

Want to support the site? We work hard to put out the best backpacker resources on the web, for free! It’s all about helping out our tribe of awesome backpacker readers [that’s you!]. Want to know how you can show your support – find out here!

For the sake of transparency, some of the links in our content are affiliate links. This means that if you book your accommodation, buy a book or sort your insurance, we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. I only link to stuff I’ve actually used and never endorse products or services that are not up to scratch. Thanks for your support.